Shared by its participants
TDI — Cybernetic Futures
David Joseph, Margeret Heath and Krishan Mathis
Open questions
25 published items with open questions, grouped by the kind of work they need. An item can be accepted and still have work left on it.
Other unfinished reasoning 25
Define first successWhat observable outcome in the first two months would give founding participants reason to continue? Test whether the working boundary includes the groups whose agency or conditions would change.GoalProposedTDI helps groups shape flourishing futures together.What are we trying to achieve?Clarify network roleWork through whether TDI should perform any metasystem functions, how it would connect to other groups, and where its skills and interests meet an unmet need.Success factorProposedPeople across fields investigate shared problems.What are we trying to achieve?Test governanceClarify how the core group, contributors and public participants share decision rights, and how independent funding would support those rights.Success factorProposedParticipants retain agency in shaping their futures.What are we trying to achieve?Clarify publication boundaryAgree what is collectively publishable, who can consent to the release of local material, and when named attribution is appropriate.ConditionProposedContributors retain attribution when work is shared.What are we trying to achieve?Find concrete caseIdentify an inquiry that stalled after a gathering. Check where follow-through broke down before linking it to a cause.ProblemProposedSome conference conversations do not lead to follow-through.What stands in the way?Verify demandIdentify groups already making a decision, the methods they have tried, and what those methods leave unresolved.ObservationProposedThe draft reports demand for collective methods.What stands in the way?Check comparisonLook for groups already combining these practices and determine which gap remains on the first question TDI chooses.ProblemProposedSystems inquiry and futures work seldom happen together.What stands in the way?Test diagnosisFind an actual response that missed a specific cross-domain interaction and check whether fragmented expertise, institutional incentives or some other cause best explains it.ConnectionProposed“An inquiry confined to one domain may omit feedback and spillovers that materially change the assessment of a response.” contributes to “The draft argues that existing responses are fragmented relative to the interconnected problems they address.”What stands in the way?Test decision rightsThis is an inferred design tension. Test whether a core can steward process, a swarm can decide shared priorities and local groups can decide what they enact. Ask whether a specific decision has actually produced conflict.ConnectionProposed“One possible response to the need for continuity is to give the core final authority over shared priorities and outputs.” conflicts with “One possible response to the need for agency is to distribute final authority over the same shared priorities and outputs.”Where do needs pull two ways?Specify ai useTranslate the call for intensive AI use in slide 6 into a specific facilitation practice. Check it against the slide 12 aim of helping groups think and the risk of narrowing participant choices.ChangeProposedUse BICCI to support group inquiry.What will we change?Compare founding projectsCompare the three founding projects and the seed inquiries on access to a real case, capacity to produce something usable, and ability to learn within the first cycle.ChangeProposedExplore human agency through participatory scenarios.What will we change?Specify use of signalsIdentify who would act on a signal, what decision it would inform, and how the network would distinguish a useful signal from noise.ChangeProposedSense emerging change across domains.What will we change?Evaluate scenario guidanceFind a decision-maker who can assess whether the scenarios reveal a relevant option or trade-off.Predicted effectProposedScenarios expose agency risks and options.What will we change?Test regional cycleDefine what regions exchange, who acts locally, and what six-month follow-up would show. A university-hosted symposium is conditional on critical mass.ChangeProposedRegional groups share signals, act locally and reconvene.What will we change?Test negative branchIf the first experiment uses BICCI, ask the same participants about useful alternatives it surfaced and any alternatives they stopped considering. Agree who can judge both outcomes.ConnectionProposed“Develop the AI-supported Imaginarium to help groups develop their own approaches while attending to consequences, boundaries and human agency.” contributes to “Participants may defer to the AI’s framing and spend less time considering alternatives raised by other participants.”What will we change?Specify first trialChoose a first topic, a real local setting, a feedback provider and an observation opportunity. Check whether a publishable output in about two months can also be used in practice.ConnectionProposed“A swarm can use the map to agree priorities and make an output suited to a real local decision or test.” and “A participating group has the authority, time and resources to try the output in its own setting and bring back what happened.” contributes to “At least one group uses a TDI output in a real decision or experiment and reports what it could use, what it changed and what it could not use.”What will we change?Test governanceCompare evidence of delivery, participant influence and local discretion under an explicit allocation of rights.ConnectionProposed“Test an arrangement where the core maintains continuity, a swarm sets priorities within a clear remit, and local groups decide what they enact.” contributes to “Continuity and shared delivery improve while participants retain meaningful influence and local groups decide how to act.”What will we change?Test diffusionTrace actual adoption through a bridge before treating diffusion or a positive tipping point as an outcome.ConnectionProposed“Develop densely connected networks with long-range bridges so ideas and practices can travel across groups.” and “Participants use feedback from local trials to revise the output or the way TDI conducts collective inquiry.” contributes to “A practice that works in one setting may be adopted or modified by groups reached through network bridges.”What will we change?Reconcile output datesThe Nov 13 draft calls for a published output in about two months. The Nov 14 impulse calls for a December topic producing something in February and lists March publication as proposed. Clarify what must exist in February and what review or release work March allows.ObjectiveProposedPublish a first collaborative output in about two months.What has to happen first?Prioritize candidatesCompare the founding projects and seed inquiries against available contributors, a real user or decision, and a two-month scope. The draft’s seeds include space-sector questions, climate learning, local parallel economies, AI-supported collective-intelligence research and testing a viable system in practice.StepProposedChoose a first topic with a tractable question.What has to happen first?Test dependencyCheck whether capability mapping is needed before the first topic can be chosen or whether a committed group can start while the wider map develops.StepProposedMap who can contribute and what they can take on.What has to happen first?Scope dependenciesCheck which offers are needed for this inquiry. The impulse leaves legal form, name, membership, money and formal role appointments outside the open session’s decision scope.StepProposedIdentify a first-cycle team and concrete offers.What has to happen first?Confirm sequenceCheck scope and responsibility for the first six months, including agreement on vision, the entry point and two exploratory events. The draft does not establish which milestones must precede one another.ActionProposedMap capabilities and compare candidate inquiries.Who does what?Identify feedback providerRecord a feedback provider, observation opportunity and expected effects once a trial is chosen. Compare the first cycle with the second-half plans for a report, audience-specific guidance, pilots, organisation and funding decisions, and symposium planning.ActionProposedInvite a local trial and review what happened.Who does what?Verify session outcomeCheck what the November session actually agreed or amended, and whether a next Friday session date was fixed. The slides supply neither the date nor a record of agreement.ActionProposedWrite a first protocol with the chosen topic and team.Who does what?These come from the commons' own record of unfinished reasoning, and from disputed items. No deadline, owner or priority is shown because none is recorded.