TDI — Cybernetic Futures
David Joseph, Margeret Heath and Krishan Mathis
Question 5 of 6 · First steps
What has to happen first?
What stands in the way of the change, and what gets past it.
- Statements
- 10
- Connections
- 8
- Open questions
- 4
How to read it. Read from left to right: each stage holds what becomes possible once the stage before it is done, and each step names the obstacle it gets past.
0 of 10 statements accepted for now · 0 of 8 connections
Proposed by Margeret Heath, AI assistant and Krishan MathisNobody has accepted anything here yet
Select a step: what it needs turns green, what it makes possible stays dark, and the rest fades.
Now
Stage 1
Nothing needed first4 steps
- Step: Identify a first-cycle team and concrete offers. Details
StepCritical path
Identify a first-cycle team and concrete offers.
KrishanProposed by Krishan Mathis.Not accepted - Step: Find a place to publish the output with attribution. Details
Step
Find a place to publish the output with attribution.
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted - Step: Agree how to investigate the chosen question. Details
Step
Agree how to investigate the chosen question.
MargeretProposed by Margeret Heath.Not accepted - Step: Choose a first topic with a tractable question. Details
Step
Choose a first topic with a tractable question.
Gets past
The first topic is still open in the draft.
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted
Next
Stage 2
After stage 12 steps
- Step: Assign responsibility for delivery and review. Details
StepCritical path
Assign responsibility for delivery and review.
Needs
- Identify a first-cycle team and concrete offers.
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted - Step: Write protocol v0.1 against the selected topic. Details
Step
Write protocol v0.1 against the selected topic.
Needs
- Choose a first topic with a tractable question.
KrishanProposed by Krishan Mathis.Not accepted
Then
Stage 3
After stage 21 objective
- Objective: Publish a first collaborative output in about two months. Details
ObjectiveCritical path
Publish a first collaborative output in about two months.
Needs
- Choose a first topic with a tractable question.
- Agree how to investigate the chosen question.
- Assign responsibility for delivery and review.
- Find a place to publish the output with attribution.
MargeretProposed by Margeret Heath.Not accepted
Not yet in order
No connection says what these steps are needed for or what they need.
- Step: Map who can contribute and what they can take on. Details
Step
Map who can contribute and what they can take on.
Proposed by Margeret Heath and Krishan Mathis.Not accepted
Step · Stage 1 · Critical path
Proposed
Identify the question each person wants answered and what they would actually do. Relevant offers include methods, a host, funding routes, technical help, and teaching materials.
Proposed by
- Krishan Mathis
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
Nothing is recorded as needed first, so it could start now.
Needed for
- Assign responsibility for delivery and review.Not accepted
Delivered by
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Use gatherings to map, decide and return to local work.Puts into practice · The change
Open questions
- Scope dependencies
Step · Stage 1
Proposed
Identify a publication route that makes the first output accessible and preserves authorship where appropriate.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
Nothing is recorded as needed first, so it could start now.
Needed for
Delivered by
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Contributors retain attribution when work is shared.Developed from · The goal
Step · Stage 1
Proposed
Select methods suited to the question and identify what evidence and perspectives the inquiry needs.
Proposed by
- Margeret Heath
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
Nothing is recorded as needed first, so it could start now.
Needed for
Delivered by
Step · Stage 1
Proposed
Founding participants choose a question a defined group can use and that TDI can investigate within the first cycle.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Gets past
The discussion draft leaves the first topic for founding participants to decide.
Needs
Nothing is recorded as needed first, so it could start now.
Needed for
Delivered by
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Use gatherings to map, decide and return to local work.Puts into practice · The change
Open questions
- Prioritize candidates
Step · Stage 2 · Critical path
Proposed
Identify who is responsible for convening, preparing the output, challenging its claims and approving it for publication.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
- Identify a first-cycle team and concrete offers.Not accepted
Needed for
Delivered by
Step · Stage 2
Proposed
The impulse proposes writing protocol v0.1 in December around the chosen question, before the January–February cycle.
Proposed by
- Krishan Mathis
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
- Choose a first topic with a tractable question.Not accepted
Delivered by
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Use gatherings to map, decide and return to local work.Puts into practice · The change
Objective · Stage 3 · Critical path
Proposed
Choose and investigate a first topic collaboratively and publish an output within about two months.
Proposed by
- Margeret Heath
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Needs
- Choose a first topic with a tractable question.Not accepted
- Agree how to investigate the chosen question.Not accepted
- Assign responsibility for delivery and review.Not accepted
- Find a place to publish the output with attribution.Not accepted
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Groups can put shared insights to work locally.Developed from · The goal
Open questions
- Reconcile output dates
Step
Proposed
Hear contributor presentations and map capabilities relevant to possible first inquiries.
Proposed by
- Margeret Heath
- Krishan Mathis
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Elsewhere in the reasoning
- Map capabilities and compare candidate inquiries.Put into practice by · Actions
Open questions
- Test dependency
Where this comes from
In the Logical Thinking Process this view is a prerequisite tree. How a commons works →