Shared by its participants. Reason Commons reviewed the submission but hasn’t checked the reasoning. Who shared it →
Reason Commons
Shared by its participants

TDI — Cybernetic Futures

David Joseph, Margeret Heath and Krishan Mathis

Shared 14 November 2026
By David Joseph

Question 3 of 6 · Pulling apart

Where do needs pull two ways?

Two needs that both serve one objective, and positions that rule each other out.

Statements
5
Connections
5
Open questions
1

How to read it. Read from right to left: each position is held to meet a need, and both needs serve the objective on the left.

Shared objectiveNeedPositionProposedConflict

Assumptions under the arrows

  1. 1

    Test the assumption that coordination and delivery require the core to hold final authority.

    Assumed by AI assistant under is needed for

  2. 2

    The collaboration cannot sustain inquiry if responsibility for common work continually lapses.

    Assumed by AI assistant under is needed for

  3. 3

    The conflict applies when the two arrangements claim final authority over the same decisions.

    Assumed by AI assistant under conflicts with

  4. 4

    The network’s intended viability includes meaningful autonomy and distributed steering.

    Assumed by AI assistant under is needed for

  5. 5

    Test whether participants require final authority on all shared priorities to exercise meaningful agency.

    Assumed by AI assistant under is needed for

Where this comes from

In the Logical Thinking Process this view is a conflict cloud, also called an evaporating cloud. How a commons works →