Corruption in Kenya, 2014
From Transparency International’s 2014 Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · reconstructed by AI
Question 6 of 6 · Actions
Who does what?
Actions, and what each should achieve.
- Statements
- 9
- Connections
- 3
- Open questions
- 1
How to read it. Read each action from left to right: from its starting point, the action should produce the expected effect.
0 of 9 statements accepted for now · 0 of 3 connections
Proposed by AI assistantNobody has accepted anything here yet
Now
Stage 1
Can start now
- Action 1
Track the bill
- Illustrative condition: A reform bill is before parliament. Details
Illustrative condition
A reform bill is before parliament.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted
Action: Publish each draft and flag weakening changes. Detailsshould produceAction
Publish each draft and flag weakening changes.
Who: unassigned · proposed role: Civil society monitors
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not acceptedExpected effect: Weakening changes are public before the vote. DetailsExpected effect
Weakening changes are public before the vote.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted - Illustrative condition: A reform bill is before parliament. Details
Next
Stage 2
After stage 1
- Action 2after 1
Brief MPs and the public
- From action 1: Weakening changes are public before the vote. Details
From action 1
Weakening changes are public before the vote.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted - Illustrative condition: Some MPs back the bill. Details
Illustrative condition
Some MPs back the bill.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted
Action: Brief MPs and the public on flagged changes. Detailsshould produceAction
Brief MPs and the public on flagged changes.
Who: unassigned · proposed role: A coalition of civil society and religious organisations
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not acceptedExpected effect: The bill passes with fewer weakening changes. DetailsExpected effect
The bill passes with fewer weakening changes.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not acceptedDeliversCommitted MPs carry the bills. · stage 2A broad coalition keeps up pressure. · stage 1
- From action 1: Weakening changes are public before the vote. Details
Then
Stage 3
After stage 2
- Action 3after 2
Follow up a year on
- From action 2: The bill passes with fewer weakening changes. Details
From action 2
The bill passes with fewer weakening changes.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted - Illustrative condition: The bill has become law. Details
Illustrative condition
The bill has become law.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not accepted
Action: A year on, report what has been put into effect. Detailsshould produceAction
A year on, report what has been put into effect.
Who: unassigned · proposed role: Civil society monitors
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not acceptedExpected effect: Implementation gaps are on public record. DetailsExpected effect
Implementation gaps are on public record.
From Samira Lindner, Transparency International
Proposed by AI assistant.Not acceptedDeliversReform bodies have secure budgets. · stage 1Each body's mandate is settled. · stage 1
- From action 2: The bill passes with fewer weakening changes. Details
Illustrative condition · Action 1
Proposed
A bill to put an anti-corruption reform into effect is before parliament.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · p. 9, bills to operationalise the constitution
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Expected effect · Action 1
Proposed
Weakening changes are public before the vote.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · pp. 9–10
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Action 1 · Stage 1
Proposed
Publish each draft of the bill side by side and flag any change that weakens it.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Who
Who: unassigned · proposed role: Civil society monitors
Starts from
- A reform bill is before parliament.Not accepted
Should produce
- Weakening changes are public before the vote.Not accepted
Delivers
- Bills are tracked so weakening is seen.Step · stage 2
Open questions
- Find a group that would try these steps.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · pp. 9–10, bills weakened before passing
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Illustrative condition · Action 2
Proposed
Some members of parliament are committed to the bill.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · p. 14, APNAC Kenya
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Expected effect · Action 2
Proposed
Members of parliament are publicly asked to account for weakening changes, and the bill passes with fewer of them.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · p. 13, civil society criticised watered-down legislation
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Action 2 · Stage 2
Proposed
Brief committed members of parliament and the public on each flagged change, through newspapers and community radio.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Who
Who: unassigned · proposed role: A coalition of civil society and religious organisations
Starts from
- Weakening changes are public before the vote.Not accepted
- Some MPs back the bill.Not accepted
Should produce
- The bill passes with fewer weakening changes.Not accepted
Comes after
- Publish each draft and flag weakening changes.Action 1Not accepted
Delivers
- Committed MPs carry the bills.Step · stage 2
- A broad coalition keeps up pressure.Step · stage 1
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · p. 5, budget hearings advertised in newspapers and community radio
Makes a related point; the statement goes beyond it.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Illustrative condition · Action 3
Proposed
The bill has become law.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · pp. 7–8, laws passed but not implemented
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Expected effect · Action 3
Proposed
Any gap between the law and its implementation is on public record.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · pp. 7–8, implementation lacking
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Action 3 · Stage 3
Proposed
A year on, report whether the law's regulations, budget and mandates have been put into effect, using audit reports and public records.
Proposed by
- AI assistantSelected, worded and connected this; it cannot accept anything
Accepted by
Nobody has accepted this yet.
Who
Who: unassigned · proposed role: Civil society monitors
Starts from
- The bill passes with fewer weakening changes.Not accepted
- The bill has become law.Not accepted
Should produce
- Implementation gaps are on public record.Not accepted
Comes after
- Brief MPs and the public on flagged changes.Action 2Not accepted
Delivers
- Reform bodies have secure budgets.Step · stage 1
- Each body's mandate is settled.Step · stage 1
Where this comes from
Samira Lindner, Transparency International, Overview of corruption and anti-corruption in Kenya · Anti-Corruption Helpdesk brief · p. 9, all regulations must also be implemented
Inferred by the AI; this connection is not established by the source.
A credit says where an idea comes from, not that its author agrees with this wording. None of the people credited has reviewed it.
Where this comes from
In the Logical Thinking Process this view is a transition tree. How a commons works →